Valentine’s Day – a marketer’s dream or a dilemma? On the one hand, UK consumers are expected to spend £2.1bn this year on gifts, experiences, and celebrations. On the other, cultural shifts are reshaping its relevance. The reality is that traditional romantic narratives no longer resonate with everyone. Nearly half of Brits said they were indifferent to Valentine’s Day in a 2023 survey conducted by Virgin, with 13% outright hating it. An increasing number of consumers are either opting out or redefining how they mark the day.

It’s a paradox that reflects a broader challenge for marketers – how do brands navigate cultural ‘moments’ that are both commercial goldmines yet also evolving (and sometimes contested) customs? Are there lessons we can draw from Valentine’s Day that apply to marketing strategies across the year?

1. The power of tradition versus the demand for change

Valentine’s Day, like many seasonal marketing moments, is rooted in long-established social norms. For decades, brands have leaned into predictable themes: red roses, candlelit dinners, and the all-important grand romantic gesture. These tropes have helped deliver impressive sales lifts for brands (and, yes, have also helped support negative gender stereotyping but that’s one for another day.)

As cultural attitudes evolve, so too must the narratives that underpin major marketing opportunities.

We’ve already seen how Christmas, once the bastion of nuclear family-centric advertising, has expanded to include stories of chosen families, multi-generational gatherings, and diverse traditions.

Valentine’s Day is now following suit. The rise of Galentine’s Day, Palentine’s Day and even Malentine’s Day, reflect a broader consumer appetite for inclusivity and personalisation and it’s so refreshing.

Instead of a single, one-size-fits-all campaign, the smart money is on multiple strands of messaging that speak to different audience segments.

While tradition still holds commercial power, successful brands are those that adapt it, and shape it, rather than rigidly adhering to outdated norms.

A brilliant example is Toblerone and its 2023 ‘Love Insurance’ campaign. What could be more traditional at Valentine’s Day than chocolate, and what could be more unorthodox than celebrating ‘situationships’, Pip Heywood, managing director of online greetings company Thortful tells me. “The creative was exquisite and the redemption mechanic – buy a limited edition chocolate bar which comes with its own love insurance – was genius. A neat alternative campaign at a time when tropes abound,” she adds.

Heinz on its mission to move ‘at the speed of culture’ to create an ad in five days

2. Beyond tokenism – authenticity matters

Every year, we see brands attempt to capitalise on cultural shifts, sometimes missing the mark entirely. The difference between a successful campaign and one that feels like an opportunistic cash grab often comes down to authenticity.

A brand that suddenly pivots to a self-love message in February, for example, without any prior commitment to wellness or empowerment, risks consumer scepticism. It’s a lesson that applies across the marketing calendar. Pride Month, International Women’s Day, Black History Month: all demand more than lip service and token brand gestures, with the best campaigns looking and feeling more like ‘movements’ versus moments.

As consumers become increasingly attuned to whether a brand’s messaging aligns with its values year-round, it’s the companies that build trust through sustained engagement with a cause or issue that will have an easier time pivoting when culture shifts. Those that opportunistically latch onto cultural moments will suffer.

“I’m all for focusing on different perspectives to find a new way into ‘traditional’ events. But a brand deciding that it will broaden its audience on Valentine’s Day by simply appealing to people who aren’t in a romantic relationship isn’t enough by itself,” John Harrison, vice-president of marketing at Expedia Group told me when I asked him about brands pivoting to self-love or friendship-focused Valentine campaigns.

By showing up with cultural awareness, and embracing audience insight, Gucci has leveraged a traditional marketing moment to create something that feels authentic, modern, distinctive and meaningful.

It’s not just that simply deciding to do so would likely come off as inauthentic but also that without rich consumer insight driving that decision you can’t expect your marketing to really land with consumers. “There has to be a creative leap to get to a great idea,” Harrison observes, adding that playing it safe is rarely the route to great creative work. “Honestly, I worry that sometimes as an industry, our desire not to alienate anyone can lead to blandness. We are so desperate to appeal to everyone, that in the end we appeal to no one.”

Heywood echos this need for genuine consumer insight if brands want to rethink how they approach traditional marketing moments like Valentine’s Day, and the importance of finding a compelling and relevant way in for a brand. “People can sniff a fake from a mile off. Say, for instance, you’re going to lean into Galentine’s Day and celebrate female friendships, do it in a way that feels real, not obvious or forced. Don’t replay a cliché on loop – focus on the depth of true connection with less emphasis on your brand or product.”

The future of marketing is inclusive, not because it’s current, but because it’s necessary

3. Flexibility is key in a fragmented consumer landscape

Once upon a time, seasonal marketing was relatively straightforward: mass-market campaigns pushed out far and wide across traditional media channels. Today, consumer preferences are of course more fragmented than ever. Yes, some audiences remain deeply engaged in traditional Valentine’s Day messaging, but others are up for something completely different. Case in point: half of Gen Z individuals would rather spend Valentine’s Day with their pet versus a partner.

This kind of reimagining of tradition means brands need to be more flexible in how they approach calendar marketing moments. Instead of a single, one-size-fits-all campaign, the smart money is on multiple strands of messaging that speak to different audience segments. For example, a fashion retailer could create distinct content targeting loved-up couples, single consumers embracing self-love, friends celebrating their besties, or yes, even ‘pawrents’ and their beloved pets.

In fact, that’s precisely what Gucci has just done in its ‘Gucci Together for Valentine’s’ campaign. Yes, the hero asset is a 15-second montage that captures a variety of subtle moments and unspoken connections that we associate with love, but look further and you’ll find individual assets – video shorts and intimate portraits – of each of the characters and their differing back stories carefully served up in relevant media environments.

By showing up with cultural awareness, and embracing audience insight, Gucci has leveraged a traditional marketing moment to create something that feels authentic, modern, distinctive and meaningful – and that speaks to all of the brand’s possible audiences, versus just one segment.

Final thoughts: The marketing calendar through a cultural lens

Valentine’s Day is just one example of how culture shapes commerce – and vice versa. Mother’s Day and Father’s Day are no longer just about nuclear families, but about diverse parental figures. Christmas isn’t just about traditional family gatherings, but about chosen families and solo celebrations too. Even Black Friday has evolved from a pure sales frenzy into a moment for ethical consumption and sustainability messaging. Cultural shifts don’t mean these moments become obsolete; they just require brands to meet consumers where they are now, not where they were decades ago.

As we move through the marketing year’s peaks the key lesson remains the same: success lies not just in recognising major commercial moments and showing up with authenticity and creativity, but also in adapting them in ways that resonate with where audiences – and culture – are headed next.